The reality television landscape often serves as a crucible where everyday individuals and public figures alike are tested under extreme psychological pressure. For Ben McDonnell, a Texas-based barrel racer, podcast host, and trained actor, joining the fifth season of Peacock and NBC’s Emmy Award-winning competition series The Traitors represented an unexpected detour from his agricultural lifestyle. Over the course of the season, McDonnell emerged as a fan-favorite contestant known for his sharp wit and memorable one-liners, ultimately establishing himself as a formidable presence within the Scottish castle before his elimination in the penultimate episode.
McDonnell’s journey to the hit reality franchise began far from the Scottish Highlands, sparked by a period of extreme winter weather in Texas. Following his sudden exit from the game, McDonnell sat down for an exclusive interview to discuss the psychological toll of the competition, the reality of maintaining a multi-week deception, and the profound personal healing he experienced throughout the process.
The Path to the Scottish Highlands
Before his casting on The Traitors: New Blood, McDonnell’s television consumption had been limited until an unexpected ice storm paralyzed parts of Texas in January. Stuck indoors for days, McDonnell and his husband, AJ, began streaming the U.K. and U.S. editions of Peacock’s breakout hit. Captivated by the psychological maneuvering and atmospheric gameplay reminiscent of the classic board game Clue, McDonnell found himself hooked within a single episode.
Just two weeks after binging the series, McDonnell received a casting inquiry that would abruptly transport him from his ranch to Ardross Castle in the Scottish Highlands. Unlike many contestants who transition directly from standard reality television or public-facing careers, McDonnell brought a unique background to the castle as a trained actor and improviser with roots at The Groundlings. Despite his theatrical training, McDonnell made the calculated decision to conceal his acting credentials from his fellow castmates, choosing instead to lean entirely into his authentic identity as a Texas cowboy while quietly utilizing his performance skills to navigate the social dynamics of the game.
Surviving the Ultimate Psychological Experiment
Entering the production with the firm expectation that producers would assign him the role of a Traitor, McDonnell experienced initial disorientation upon learning he had been selected as a Faithful. This realization fundamentally shifted his strategic approach. While Traitors must operate with calculated foresight and long-term deception, Faithfuls are forced to navigate a high-stakes popularity contest characterized by paranoia, shifting alliances, and high school-esque social dynamics.

Filming for The Traitors requires absolute isolation, separating contestants from their families, work commitments, and digital devices for the duration of their tenure. For McDonnell, who actively maintains a digital presence and hosts the weekly comedy podcast It’s Ben a Week, relinquishing his mobile phone presented an unexpected psychological hurdle. He noted the surreal nature of going completely dark online, joking that acquaintances back home likely assumed he had checked into a rehabilitation facility.
Despite the intense anxiety generated by the daily roundtable discussions and the looming threat of banishment, McDonnell approached his eventual elimination with notable calm. Having packed his belongings ahead of time—complete with a statement fur coat originally intended for the finale—he noted that a sense of peace came over him on the morning of his departure. Rather
than feeling bitter about his exit, McDonnell expressed satisfaction with his longevity in the game, noting that by the final stages, he believed other contestants facing severe personal hardships were more deserving of the potential $250,000 grand prize.
Unexpected Personal Healing and Brotherhood
Beyond the strategic mechanics of the game, McDonnell’s time on The Traitors yielded profound personal breakthroughs. Growing up as an openly gay youth in a small town in Wisconsin, McDonnell faced significant bullying and a severe domestic trauma when his stepfather discovered his sexual orientation. These formative experiences left McDonnell with lingering discomfort surrounding male relationships, leading him to cultivate friendships predominantly with women and approach the co-ed cast with guarded expectations.
However, the immersive and emotionally vulnerable environment of the castle dismantled those defensive barriers. Engaging in candid conversations with fellow contestants about their personal backgrounds fostered a deep sense of camaraderie. McDonnell revealed that the genuine acceptance he received from his castmates provided an unexpected form of emotional healing, allowing him to feel valued for his authentic self rather than merely his social utility. Consequently, he departed the series with a sense of personal fulfillment that transcended the competition’s monetary stakes.
Behind the Scenes of a Television Phenomenon
McDonnell’s reflections offer a rare glimpse into the rigorous production schedule and hidden realities of bringing the hit format to life. Viewers accustomed to compressed, high-intensity edits of roundtable sessions often fail to realize that these confrontations frequently span up to two hours. Throughout these grueling debates, host Alan Cumming maintains his character with unwavering focus, sitting through extended sessions without breaking persona.

McDonnell’s interactions with Cumming extended beyond the formal parameters of production. During a rare behind-the-scenes moment of levity, a conversation about pigs inspired McDonnell to name a newly acquired piglet on his Texas ranch "Alan Cunningham." Upon sharing photographic evidence with Cumming, the actor expressed immense amusement, cementing a memorable connection between the reality contestant and the celebrated host.
Future Endeavors and Podcast Expansion
With his elimination broadcast and the restriction of confidentiality lifted, McDonnell is expanding the scope of his weekly comedy and pop culture podcast, It’s Ben a Week. Having recorded episodes and managed social media rollouts in advance prior to his departure for Scotland, McDonnell is now opening his platform to fellow alumni from The Traitors to discuss the unseen dynamics of the competition.
While scripted television and film remain McDonnell’s primary professional aspirations—with upcoming appearances in independent projects such as the western film Cowboy—he remains open to further television opportunities, expressing openness to formats like Dancing With the Stars. Furthermore, residing in proximity to acclaimed filmmaker Taylor Sheridan in Texas has fueled aspirations to secure roles in grounded, character-driven projects that bridge his theatrical background with his authentic cowboy lifestyle.
As the two-part finale of The Traitors approaches its broadcast on Peacock, McDonnell’s journey stands as a testament to the unpredictable nature of reality television, where intense strategic competition can unexpectedly yield lasting personal transformation, professional visibility, and enduring friendships.







